|
A
number of legislative changes have been made in recent years, starting in
Finance Act 2005, to treat a number of different financing techniques which
are economically equivalent to debt finance as AFAs.
In
each case the AFA is treated as a loan relationship for corporation tax
purposes and the “alternative finance return” is treated as interest for the
purposes of income tax and corporation tax. The AFAs specified in law are
based on a number of Shari’a compliant financing techniques namely murabaha,
mudaraba, diminishing musharaka, wakala and sukuk. However, there is no
requirement for an AFA to be Shari’a compliant.
Section 98 Finance Act 2006 permits amendments to the tax treatment of AFAs
by secondary legislation. This power allows the introduction of provisions
relating to new arrangements, but does not allow for amendments to the rules
on existing arrangements.
Legislation will be introduced in Finance Bill 2008 to amend the power to
make provision relating to AFAs by secondary legislation. The amended
power will introduce a further power to permit amendments to existing tax
rules on AFA and will have effect on and after the date that Finance Bill
2008 receives Royal Assent.
|
Our view
Whilst any powers to amend primary legislation by regulations are of
concern, this power should be welcomed. We are aware of a number of
amendments which have been suggested to enable the loan relationship and
associated rules to be more effective, which have not been made due to
the premium on Finance Bill space each year.
The new power should enable problems identified with the primary
legislation to be amended outside the Finance Bill constraint. |
|